We looked at
different comparative
reviews:
MP3.com,
Consumer
Reports,
PC World,
PC
Magazine,
Smart Computing and
Wired.
From those 7
different reviews we
assigned a scoring
system of:
3 points for a first
place ranking on the
review
2 points for a second
place ranking on the
review
1 point for a third
place ranking on the
review
.75 for a forth place
ranking on the review
.5 for a fifth place
ranking on the review
With the Cnet.com The
iRiver h120 and Rio
Karma were tied for
second place so we gave
those two players two
points each. While the
Creative Zen Touch
finished third in their
score it was the fourth
product so therefore
given a 4th place score
. The PC Mag gave
their highest score to
the iRiver H140 which is
exact replica of the
H120 but has a 40 GB
hard-drive so we
therefore gave the 3
points to the H120 since
all other players
reviewed were 20 GB.
Score:
Apple iPod
13.75
iRiver H120 10.5
Rio Karma
6
For a complete
overview of the MP3
Player Market