MICRODRIVE MP3 PLAYERS                                                            

 iPod Mini

   Creative Micro

  Rio Carbon

Comparison

PORTABLE MEDIA
HOME AUDIO
HOME VIDEO
PHOTOGRAPHY

 

 
Google
Web Uber-Review
 MP3 PLAYERS
MICRO HARD-DRIVE  PLAYERS
1.5 GB - 5GB
Micro Hard-Drive  Players:  The hard-drive group can be divided into two groups: large capacity(20 GB or higher) or microdrive (1.5-5GB).Micro hard-drive players ride the line between full-size hard drive-based MP3 players and compact, flash-based players, these models aim to give you the best of both worlds by using miniature hard drives (about 1 inch in diameter) with capacities of up to 5GB. The microdrive players, which tend to be palm-sized and weigh about a quarter-pound but can hold up to 2500 songs. The downfall of hard-drive players is the drive is always moving while playing therefore having the potential of skipping during exercise even with skip protection. But often that extra capacity translates into a bulkier, heavier player weighing up to 1 pound.   



Pros:

  • smaller and lighter than high-capacity players
  •  hold more tunes than flash-based models with the same price.
     

Cons:

  • You get fewer megabytes per dollar than you do with a larger player
  •  moving parts that limit physical activity, potential for skipping
     

Micro vs. Large

If you see yourself adding several new CDs to your player every week then the large-capacity player is definitely for you. To put the size of the player in perspective a 20 GB player holds 5000 songs which equals 500 ten-song CDs. If all you want is 20 CDs worth of music on you at one time then save some money and go with a micro hard-drive player.

 

 
Size hours of music amount of songs

1.5 GB

25 hrs

375 songs

4 GB

 70 hrs

1000 songs

5 GB

87 hrs

1250 songs

 

 

 

 

 

based on songs encoded at 128 kbps bit rate

TOP MICRO HARD-DRIVE MP3 PLAYERS

 

Apple iPod mini                 Rio Carbon            Creative  Zen Micro         

Photo credits to Apple, Rio and Creative

OVERVIEW
We looked at  different comparative reviews:  CNet.com,   Consumer Reports, PC World, PC Magazine, About. com and Wired test.

From those 6 different reviews we assigned a scoring system of:                                      

3 points for a first place ranking on the review    

2 points for a second place ranking on the review

1 point for a third place ranking on the review     

.75 for a forth place ranking on the review

.5 for a fifth place ranking on the review

Score:

Apple iPod Mini          15

Rio Carbon                  14

Creative Micro Zen   8

 

For a complete overview of the MP3 Player Market

Prices

All prices are MRSP

Model Name
Apple iPod mini
Rio Carbon
Creative Zen Micro
Price
$249.99
$249.99
$249.99
OUR AFFILIATES

 Click here for your favorite eBay items

 

Advertise on blogs